Review: Celtic HIP from Makaris

by Andrew J. Sammut
Published October 3, 2022

The Galant David Rizzio. Makaris. Olde Focus Recordings FCR921

Masked-up members of Markaris, and a bottle of gin. From right: Fiona Gillespie, Paul Morton, Caitlin Hedge, Kivie Cahn-Lippman, Sian Ricketts, Doug Balliett, Manami Mizumoto, and Elliot Figg. (Photo by Ryan Streber)

Call it a productive case of mistaken identity. The New York-centered early-music ensemble Makaris’ new album revisits Scottish song arrangements with a fantastical connection.

Many works published during the 18th-century vogue for Scottish music list the composer as one David Rizzio—despite the fact that this 16th-century secretary to Mary, Queen of Scots, who was murdered after an alleged affair with his queen, had never written a note of music. By some accounts, his ghost still haunts the tower at Holyrood Palace. The liner notes best explain the complicated connection between Rizzio and Galant-era composers and arrangers, but suffice it to say that this fictionalized composer frames a heartwarming, often foot-tapping disc.

The Galant David Rizzio explores a slightly earlier period than the works on Makaris’ debut, Wisps in the Dell (and which included different personnel). The new recording is a beautiful intersection of folk melodies and dance rhythms with the airy textures, refined gestures, and virtuosic asides of the Galant style. Some arrangements sound straight out of the drawing room, like Johann Christian Bach’s scoring of “Beneath a Green Shade,” of graceful vocal lines over oboe and strings. We can imagine the lyrics about who “deserves to be reckon’d an ass” and syncopated hee-haws of “Push About the Brisk Bowl” scandalized some listeners.

Other pieces bridge the salon and saloon. “The Broom of Cowdenknowes” blends Celtic twang with an elegant but bittersweet melody. The Italian influence on the English musical scene is also on display, for example, in the florid violin introducing Geminiani’s setting of “The Lass of Peaty’s Mill” or the instrumental recitative in “The Last Time I Came O’er the Moor.”

Fiona Gillespie connects everything through her assured, responsive lead vocals. “An Thou Were My Ain Thing” shows off her focused soprano and sheer warmth of tone. For “Bessy Bell and Mary Gray,” her voice takes on a steely, trance-like quality as she mourns plague victims. Then, her trills and aspirated phrases on “Fickle Jenny” convey frustration alongside flirtation. She also brings out the musicality of the Scottish accent, like the elongated vowels recalling a beloved’s “smooth” skin or the “mither” she ejects in comic defiance of her parent’s chosen suitor.

The instrumentalists match Gillespie in sensitivity and command of this repertoire, settling into the range of texture, moods, and grooves across 26 tracks. Several instrumentals—including imaginative original arrangements by band members—highlight the tight interplay that translates into a spontaneous feel. “The Flowers of Edinburgh” downright swings in violinist Caitlin Hedge’s arrangement of this traditional reel. Paul Morton and Doug Balliett’s arrangement of “William’s Ghost” combines metallic plucks on cittern over bass and harpsichord, to spectral effect.

Solos and obbligatos also highlight individual ensemble members. Hedge’s varied tone and animated ornaments make for a refreshing interpretation of the “Tweed Side” variations from Veracini’s Violin Sonata in A Major (Op. 12, No. 9, III. “Scozzese”). Sian Ricketts’s oboe and recorder adds color in pastoral settings, raucous commentaries, and wistful asides. Violinist Manami Mizumoto joins Hedge for a sparkling trio sonata to start James Oswald’s collection of dances from the pantomime Queen Mab, which closes the disc with a whirling jig for the whole ensemble.

Oktaven Audio of Mount Vernon, New York, puts the sound up close and personal, maintaining the music’s immediacy and balance. Cellist/bass violist Kivie Cahn-Lipman’s program notes succinctly explain Rizzio’s story as well as the Gaelic terms and references in the texts. In short, the whole album is a success—and one of this reviewer’s favorite releases of 2022.

Andrew J. Sammut has written for All About Jazz, The Boston Classical Review, The Boston Musical Intelligencer, Early Music America, The Syncopated Times, and his blog. He also works as a freelance copyeditor and writer.


More CD Reviews:

CD Review: Cantata Collective Opens Its Bach Account

Posted on
The Oakland-based Cantata Collective opens its Bach series with a sampling of the solo-cantata repertoire in an engaging, intimate setting of one-to-a-part performances. This rewarding new disc features two gifted…

Recent EMA Recording & Book Reviews

Jewish Heroism, Italian Oratorio

Published:
A new, complete recording of Alessandro Stradella's 1673 biblical oratorio 'Ester' looks deeper than its Italian Counter-Reformation inspiration and goes back to the story's Jewish roots, centered on themes of resistance and survival owing to one woman's courage. Camerata Grimani and its strong Italian and American cast perform with rhetorical flair and, refreshingly, a Mediterranean sense of expression.
Read More Jewish Heroism, Italian Oratorio

Going Solo with Viadana

Published:
Italian composer and Franciscan friar Lodovico Viadana, born c. 1560 near Mantua, was a pioneer in the new expressive monody in church music. The Viadana Collective makes its stunning recording debut with music from their namesake's 'Centum sacri concentus ab una voce sola,' codifying the sound of solo voices with instrumental accompaniment.
Read More Going Solo with Viadana

Exuberant Bach from Mahan Esfahani

Published:
Mahan Esfahani's J.S. Bach recordings, on harpsichord and clavichord, are rich in virtuosity and imagination. Although the music on this newest album, including preludes, inventions, and sinfonias, was composed for teaching purposes, Esfahani sees beyond the printed page and manages to coax a vocal character from his instrument.
Read More Exuberant Bach from Mahan Esfahani

More News & Reviews

Scroll to Top