Published April 28, 2017

Viola da gamba players Robert Smith and Paolo Pandolfo perform with elegance and panache on their new disc.
Viola da gamba players Robert Smith and Paolo Pandolfo perform with elegance and panache on their new disc.


The Excellency of Hand: English Viola da Gamba Duos
Robert Smith and Paolo Pandolfo, viola da gambas
Resonus RES10186

By Donald Rosenberg

CD REVIEW — The title of this captivating disc featuring gambists Robert Smith and Paolo Pandolfo was inspired by a passage from The Division Violist, an instruction manual by the English composer Christopher Simpson (c. 1604-1669):

ExcellencyCover 400A Ground is written out on [2 sheets of] paper; one for the organ etc.; the other for him that plays the viol who, having the  ground as his theme, plays such variety of descant or division as his skill and present invention suggest. In this manner of play, a man may show the excellency both of his hand and invention, to the delight and admiration of those that hear him.

There can be no doubt that the four hands on this release animating duos by Simpson and compatriots John Jenkins (1592-1678) and Simon Ives (1600-1662) are excellent in every way. To say, however, that Smith and Pandolfo “invent” the music before them would be misleading. The art of improvisation may have been a requirement when the three English composers created their duos, but the 22 pieces on the menu of The Excellence of Hand represent the music as written.

As suggested in the quote above, the viol player took the ground and “divided” long notes into shorter, faster ones by way of ornamentation. The result could be graceful and lyrical or fiery and virtuosic. Both examples are here in abundance as Smith and Pandolfo make their expressive way through numerous divisions (and airs with divisions), many of which are preceded by brief preludes — some lasting less than 20 seconds. Not all of the preludes date from the 17th century: Smith is the composer of a Prelude in A minor whose harmonic pungencies are definitely of our time.

Robert Smith composed one of the disc's preludes.
Robert Smith composed one of the disc’s preludes.

The range of atmospheres and textures in these pieces is remarkable. The viols converse in the most charming manner, when they aren’t sharing grave sentiments or trying to outdo each other with torrents of lightning-quick notes. As employed by Ives, Jenkins, Simpson, and Smith, the viols evoke colors and emotions that bring out unanticipated aspects of these instruments.

Or does this have something to do with the exceptional artistry of certain British and Italian viol players? Smith and Pandolfo are of like mind wherever the pieces send them. More than an hour’s worth of duos might prove a challenge if the music and the performances were less than compelling. But there’s never any danger that the ear will wander as Smith and Pandolfo  immerse themselves in these delectables.

The gambists aren’t afraid to produce robust sonorities in the most extroverted passages, or to whisper to one another when the mood turns austere. In many of the divisions, they share and interweave phrases with a seamless dexterity that rivets the attention. The end result, with a nod to Simpson, is “delight” that can only elicit an active listener’s bountiful The “admiration.”

Donald Rosenberg is editor of EMAg, The Magazine of Early Music America.

Recent EMA Recording & Book Reviews

Handel’s ‘Israel in Egypt’ Rework’d

Jeannette Sorrell's adaptation of Handel's popular 'Israel in Egypt' cuts, re-orders, restores, and replaces music and text throughout the oratorio. But Handel didn't leave us with a 'definitive' edition, and Sorrell's version is so artistically logical that someone new to the work might not know anything is missing. Apollo's Fire and the outstanding vocal and instrumental soloists make a compelling case.
Read More Handel’s ‘Israel in Egypt’ Rework’d

Bach Worship? It’s Complicated.

People who love Wagner operas can separate his music from his toxic beliefs. Yet J.S. Bach's 'superlative ability to move listeners' and status as 'a pinnacle of Western art' brushes aside the composer's harsh theology and often intolerant personal philosophy. In this collection of essays, Bach scholar Michael Marissen warns us to 'not soften or assimilate this figure to our own preferences, no matter how much we find inspiration, solace, or transcendence in his art.'
Read More Bach Worship? It’s Complicated.

More News & Reviews

Scroll to Top